The Real Effects of HVCC

The HVCC (Home Valuation Code of Conduct) law that became in effect on May 1 was designed to "protect" consumers by creating a process in which the appraisal reports are done based on unbiased opinions and without any influence from realtors and loan originators. Under this law, loan originators are no longer allowed to have any direct contact with appraisers during a real estate purchase transaction. The orders are processed through an independent 3rd party company.

With all its good intention, the real effects we have seen under this new process have been quite detrimental to consumers. The average cost for an appraisal has increased by about 40%. The average cost used to be around $375 for a property under $1mil value, an equivolent report today costs around $500. That's real cash taken from consumer's pocket.

For refinance borrowers, especially those whose equity in their house may have eroded to just around 20%, the new process has become an expensive exploration. In the past, we could at least call an appraiser to get a rough estimate of the approximate value without having to go through a full inspection (thus not incurring a cost to the consumers). Under the new law, because we can't have any direct contact with appraisers, the consumers will have to spend the $500 upfront to find out if refinance is a possibility.

There are many other holes in the new process that create new challenges during a transaction. I just hope that the regulators are listening to what people saying, and make some real senses out of this honorable idealistic quest.